Full Article Text

Theater:  New  Musical  'Giant'  Has  Big
Ambitions...And  Scores
GIANT *** 1/2 out of ****
PUBLIC  THEATER,  NYC
It's your choice: try and grab a ticket now while this show is at the Public or you'll be
buying a ticket to see it on Broadway. Don't worry if you can't snag a seat during its verylimited run (which I assume will be extending at least a little). Giant is a wonderfully
intimate and complex show, but it will fill up a Broadway stage with ease.
You know the story from the novel by Edna Ferber or the somewhat leaden film best
known for containing James Dean's final performance. Giant tells the story of Texas and it
tells the story of Bick Benedict which amounts to the same thing. Spanning almost thirtyyears, the show begins like the novel, with Bick and his wife Leslie (Kate Baldwin) havingit out late in their marriage and then jumps back in time to show where it all began.
Bick is a rancher, burning with a passion to breed cattle and feed the world, working side
by side with his tough as leather sister Lux (Michele Pawk). Imagine her shock when Bickis sidetracked from marrying the girl next door (mind you, "next door" is 80 miles away)and comes home from a trip with a new thoroughbred horse and a new bride. Then thesoap opera really begins: ranch hand Jett Rink (PJ Griffith in the James Dean role)
develops a hankering for Leslie and an even bigger hankering for money when he strikes
oil on what was thought to be a worthless scrap of land.
Soon a dark stain is seeping in everywhere: Leslie feels the town (essentially owned by
Bick) features shabby homes for their workers. She tries to befriend the Mexicans, learn
Spanish and open Bick's heart to injustice all at the same time. He just wants to rope and
ride the range and be a rancher. In the nimble book by Sybille Pearson, we speed alonguntil their two children are young adults with daughter Lil Lux (Mackenzie Mauzy) clearlyin love with the ranch while the stammering, bookish son Jordy (Bobby Steggert) has hismother's social conscience -- the fact that dating a Mexican girl is an act of rebellion is justicing on the cake.
April 29, 2014
This is the print preview:
Back to normal view »
Posted: 11/16/2012 1:17 am
On and on the story tumbles, but that's the bare bones plot. This is a musical with songs
and score by Michael John LaChiusa and it's his most tuneful work since The  Wild  Party
(that woefully unappreciated show that will be a hit when it's revived some day soon).
Without sacrificing any of the sophistication he has always been capable of and wisely
without trying to incorporate a heavy Texas twang, LaChiusa delivers a collection of songsthat are both direct and very ambitious.
The show begins quietly and the first song is in Spanish, a charmer called "Aurelia
Dolores." It establishes a pattern. Without becoming heavy-handed and turning this
melodrama into an issue show, the Mexican roots of Texas and its people are always
present -- often as servants, mind you, but sometimes as love interests and always as
people. Spanish songs appear throughout the show at key moments and Mexican
characters give voice to their dreams. This isn't a modernizing touch: Ferber was a
member of the Algonquin Circle and not an author of bodice-rippers. Her works often
contained a strong focus on racial prejudice and other social issues (notably Show  Boat , of
course).
We then launch into Bick's love of the land, "Did Spring Come To Texas?," a tune that
might have come from Oklahoma , musically if not geographically. Brian D'Arcy James has
a quiet strength throughout the show that anchors it perfectly. And he's matched everymoment by Kate Baldwin as Leslie. Their easy intimacy in her father's library just minutesafter meeting makes you believe in love at first sight. Like Rock Hudson and ElizabethTaylor in the film version, they are both stars of the first order. Unlike Hudson, James canreally act and they both sing with ease.
This is a decades-spanning show but it never feels "big" as in a spectacle. Director Michael
Greif keeps a laser focus on these characters. There are rousing moments like a BBQhoedown, a wedding that slides painfully into a funeral, and a wonderfully restrainedfinale but this is not a widescreen epic. You're always leaning into to listen and watch, notblown back by unnecessary fuss.
Greif's rare misstep here in his direction is with Pawk as Luz. She's a fine actress but goes
too far over into hokum in her acting and singing, signaling her disdain for Bick's newwife in such broad terms it feels more like Ma Kettle. She barks out "No Time ForSurprises" and then treats Leslie with such venom, you expect her to twirl a mustache. It'sjust a question of tamping her down, since essentially Pawk is well cast. With this show,less is definitely more.
Similarly, Katie Thompson has a knock-'em-dead show-stopper in Act One with "He
Wanted A Girl," the song where she reveals her pain over losing Bick (the only man she'sever loved and the person both families intended her to marry). Did she have to lose himto this new girl who's afraid of wide open spaces and doesn't know a thing aboutranching? It's a bravura turn she delivers in a marvelous voice, only to spoil the mood justa tad by over-acting in the next moment when talking to Leslie. (Perhaps her emotions gotthe best of her?) Thompson has already completely won us over; she doesn't need to do athing in the scene after that and we'll still ache for her. (She's just as good in her secondact number "Midnight Blues," part of a genuinely wonderful scene where she, Leslie and afriend all share painful secrets that should play as melodrama but feels real to life.)
"Heartbreak Country" is the rare number that doesn't ring quite true; perhaps it's trying to
embody some Texas sentiment? It falls short and feels forced lyrically (though not
musically). But it's soon followed by "Topsy-Turvy," a playful song between Leslie and
Bick when they're in a hotel room trying to do something other than bicker all the time.And "My Texas" ends the act well with a rousing defense of their "country" (Texans ratherannoyingly refer to their state as their country, as Bick makes clear). It doesn't comewithout hints of further darkness -- Bick's son Jordy insists on stammering out the realfacts about the Alamo and Texas (such as the inconvenient truth that the Mexicans were
there first and the whites are the real immigrants).
Up to this point, Giant has been a very well sung, brisk, entertaining show with a fine,
large cast, some great open skies for a vista thanks to the lighting by Kenneth Posner and
effective, judicious sets by Allen Moyer. The hair and wig design by David Brian Brownalong with the costumes by Jeff Mahshie effectively capture the passage of time withyoung people growing older and adults growing old. I'll need to see the show again tofigure out how they do it, but all that pipe-laying in the first act, all that complex storythat Pearson fits in without making the show feel too much like a soap opera bears fruit inthe second act. That's where Giant reaches peaks of genuine greatness.
Like so many of the best moments in the show, the second act begins quietly. Bick is outon the range, commiserating with the memory of his now-dead sister Luz in "I Miss OurMornings." Then he launches into a number that is a companion piece to that Rodgers &Hammerstein classic "Soliloquy." In that song, of course, a young man is about to becomea father and fantasizes about what it will be like to have a son...and then worries about theheavy responsibility of having a girl. In Bick's soliloquy "That Thing," an essentially decentfather struggles with the reality of being a dad, loving his son and yet feeling that theyhave absolutely nothing in common, while reveling in the bond he enjoys with hisdaughter. It's a moving, complex number that James navigates beautifully.
It's immediately followed by another winner, "Jump," a showcase for three younger
characters. Angel (the charming Miguel Cervantes, very good in a very brief role) isgetting married and then going off to fight WW II. Lil Luz (Mackenzie Mauzy) wants herindependence but is drawn to Bobby (devilishly handsome Jon Fletcher), a boy who lovesranching just as much as she. They all sing "Jump, " a delightful winner about taking
chances, with Angel prodding Jordy to ask Juana (the pretty and sweet Natalie Cortez) out
on a date, telling Bobby to let Lil Luz know he likes her too and then maybe they can work
together so Angel can have some alone-time with his intended. It's a charmer rooted in
character thanks to the staging, the singing and the choreography by Alex Sanchez, which
is discretely strong throughout but really gets to shine here.
That's followed by yet another delight: "There Is A Child," a song in which Jordy's
sweetheart Juana expresses her dreams and they innocently flirt. LaChiusa expresses
Juana's acceptance of Jordy and his speech defect by giving Cortez a song that begins with
her remembering English lessons from her sister -- she practiced her "wh's" by saying"who" and "what" and "where" and so on while speaking into her hand to feel the breath.She shows him the technique, a simple gesture that acknowledges she knows what it's liketo struggle to speak. Jordy, shyly dipping his head but also daring to look her in the eye,practices his "wh's" too and breathes on her hand, in an intimate elocution lesson thatechoes the classic My  Fair  Lady. Steggert is an asset to any show and one of the best
talents in theater today. He captures Jordy's gentle but abashed habit of looking down, hisrefusal to keep quiet even when it's difficult to talk and the passionate heart that will drivehim to fulfill his mother's thwarted dreams of making a difference.
The melodrama kicks in again, but it feels more deserved now. The show barrels along,
with Jett given a rousing barn-burner about the changing times called "The Dog Is GonnaBark." (It's no surprise to read that Griffith fronts a rock band, after seeing hiscommanding performance on this.) Among the many wise decisions of Pearson (who alsodid the book for Baby ) was the choice to not build up the rivalry of Bick and Jett more
than it needs. Jett is still drawn to Leslie and marries a beauty queen look-alike (heck, heeven flirts with Leslie's daughter), but it's detailed quickly and neatly and then life goeson. Throughout, the show manages to capture the tumble and turmoil of the times. Butsince it doesn't pretend to tie up loose ends or follow every sub-plot to their finale, it feelsmore like a slice of life than the daytime serial that was the feature film Giant .
There's still one more remarkable number: it's the scene that we saw at the beginningwhere Bick and Leslie are having it out, discovering if there's anything left worth fightingfor in their marriage. The show ends back where it began with "The Desert," a stunnerperformed to perfection by James and Baldwin (who is luminous and groundedthroughout). They seesaw through emotions, detail their heartbreaks, discuss their dreams
and end on a quiet note of hope as Leslie points out they don't have to agree on
everything, they just have to keep talking. The couple clasps hands and the show is
essentially over.
But there's a coda, with Jordy and Juana sharing a moment of hope; Steggert as always
wins us over with ease and Cortez matches him. Even here, the show doesn't go for arousing, big number that might have felt forced, "all hat and no cattle" as they say. There'sa brief surge in singing on the chorus, but by the end it's just a young married couplefacing the future as their family and friends -- both living and dead -- stand beside them
in a moment of simple solidarity.
Small adjustments in some of the performances and a tightening of Act One (though God
knows it's pretty condensed already) should make what is already one of the best musicalsof the year even better. I think the Tony Award season just got a lot more interesting: thespring musical Matilda has some serious competition if this show transfers as it should.
And Michael John LaChiusa may have found the popular success his talent has augured
for so long.
THE  THEATER  SEASON  2012-2013 (on a four star scale)
As  You  Like  it (Shakespeare in the Park withLily Rabe) ****
Chimichangas  And  Zoloft *
Closer  Than  Ever ***
Cock ** 1/2
Harvey with Jim Parsons *
My  Children!  My  Africa! ***
Once  On  This  Island ***
Potted  Potter *
Storefront  Church ** 1/2
Title  And  Deed ***
Picture  Incomplete (NYMF) **
Flambe  Dreams (NYMF) **
Rio (NYMF) **
The  Two  Month  Rule (NYMF) *
Trouble (NYMF) ** 1/2
Stealing  Time (NYMF) **
Requiem  For  A  Lost  Girl (NYMF) ** 1/2
Re-Animator  The  Musical (NYMF) ***
Baby  Case (NYMF) ** 1/2
How  Deep  Is  The  Ocean (NYMF) ** 1/2
Central  Avenue  Breakdown (NYMF) ***
Foreverman (NYMF) * 1/2
Swing  State (NYMF) * 1/2
Stand  Tall:  A  Rock  Musical (NYMF) * 1/2
Living  With  Henry (NYMF) *
A  Letter  To  Harvey  Milk (NYMF) ** 1/2
The  Last  Smoker  In  America **
Gore  Vidal's  The  Best  Man (w new cast) ***
Into  The  Woods  at  Delacorte ** 1/2
Bring  It  On:  The  Musical **
Bullet  For  Adolf *
Summer  Shorts  Series  B:  Paul  Rudnick,  Neil  LaBute,  etc. **
Harrison,  TX ***
Dark  Hollow:  An  Appalachian  "Woyzeck" (FringeNYC) * 1/2
Pink  Milk (FringeNYC)* 1/2
Who  Murdered  Love (FringeNYC) no stars
Storytime  With  Mr.  Buttermen (FringeNYC) **
#MormonInChief (FringeNYC) **
An  Interrogation  Primer (FringeNYC) ***
An  Evening  With  Kirk  Douglas (FringeNYC) *
Sheherizade (FringeNYC) **
The  Great  Pie  Robbery (FringeNYC) ** 1/2
Independents (FringeNYC) *** 1/2
The  Dick  and  The  Rose (FringeNYC) **
Magdalen (FringeNYC) ***
Bombsheltered (FringeNYC) ** 1/2
Paper  Plane (FringeNYC) ** 1/2
Rated  M  For  Murder (FringeNYC) ** 1/2
Mallory/Valerie (FringeNYC) *
Non-Equity:  The  Musical! (FringeNYC) *
Blanche:  The  Bittersweet  Life  Of  A  Prairie  Dame (FringeNYC) *** 1/2
City  Of  Shadows (FringeNYC) ***
Forbidden  Broadway:  Alive  &  Kicking ***
Salamander  Starts  Over (FringeNYC) ***
Pieces (FringeNYC) *
The  Train  Driver ***
Chaplin  The  Musical * 1/2
Detroit ** 1/2
Heartless at Signature **
Einstein  On  The  Beach at BAM ****
Red-Handed  Otter ** 1/2
Marry  Me  A  Little **
An  Enemy  Of  The  People ** 1/2
The  Old  Man  And  The  Old  Moon *** 1/2
A  Chorus  Line  at  Papermill ***
Helen  &  Edgar ***
Grace * 1/2
Cyrano  de  Bergerac **
Who's  Afraid  Of  Virginia  Woolf? ***
Disgraced **
Annie ** 1/2
The  Heiress **
Checkers ** 1/2
Ivanov ***
Golden  Child at Signature ** 1/2
Giant at the Public *** 1/2
Scandalous * 1/2
Forever  Dusty **
The  Performers **
The  Piano  Lesson at Signature *** 1/2
Un  Ballo  In  Maschera at the Met *** 1/2 (singing) * (production) so call it ** 1/2
A  Christmas  Story:  The  Musical **
The  Sound  Of  Music at Papermill ***
My  Name  Is  Asher  Lev *** 1/2
Golden  Boy **
A  Civil  War  Christmas ** 1/2
Dead  Accounts **
The  Anarchist *
Glengarry  Glen  Ross **
Bare **
The  Mystery  Of  Edwin  Drood ** 1/2
The  Great  God  Pan ** 1/2
Thanks  for  reading.  Michael  Giltz  is  the  cohost  of  Showbiz  Sandbox ,  a  weekly  pop
culture  podcast  that  reveals  the  industry  take  on  entertainment  news  of  the  day  and
features  top  journalists  and  opinion  makers  as  guests.  It's  available   for  free  on  iTunes.
Visit  Michael  Giltz  at  his  website   and  his  daily  blog.   Download  his  podcast  of  celebrity
interviews  and  his  radio  show,  also  called  Popsurfing  and  also  available   for  free  on
iTunes.  Link  to  him  on  Netflix  and  gain   access  to  thousands  of  ratings  and  reviews.
Note :  Michael  Giltz  is  provided  with  free  tickets  to  shows  with  the  understanding  that
he  will  be  writing  a  review.
Follow  Michael  Giltz  on  Twitter:  www.twitter.com/michaelgiltz